Showing posts with label Performance analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Performance analysis. Show all posts

Monday, August 26, 2019

Performance of First Session of 17th Lok Sabha – Women MPs Top the Performance


The Budget Session of the Parliament was held from June 17th 2019 to August 7th 2019. This was the first session of the Parliament after the elections for the 17th Lok Sabha. In the past, the Parliament used to hold a short session for oath-taking after the election of the new Lok Sabha. This session would be followed by the Budget Session.

In the 17th Lok Sabha, the oath-taking session was combined with the Budget Session. Initially, the session was planned to be held from June 17th2019 to July 26th2019. It was extended to August 7th2019. During the Budget Session, Lok Sabha had sittings for 37 days and Rajya Sabha had sittings for 35 days.

Productivity – Highest in 20 Years


During this session, Lok Sabha worked for 281 hours which is 135% of the scheduled hours. This is higher than any other session of the Parliament in the past 20 years. On an average, Lok Sabha worked for 81% of its scheduled time in the past 20 years.  Rajya Sabha worked for 195 hours which is 100% of the scheduled hours. On an average,Rajya Sabha has worked for 76% of its scheduled time during a session in the past 20 years.

Questions – Highest in 20 Years for Answers

Question Hour functioned for 95% of its scheduled time inLok Sabha and, 65% inRajya Sabha during this session.During this session, 36% of the questions were answered orally in Lok Sabha by ministers. This is higher than any other session in the past 20 years. 40% of the questions received an oral answer from a minister in Rajya Sabha. This is the second highest among all sessions in the past 20 years.

On an average, 15% of the questions in Lok Sabha and 17% of the questions in Rajya Sabha received were answered orally during a session in the past 20 years.

Legislative Business is the Highest in Ten Years



The time spent by Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha during the first session is given in the chart displayed.

Lok Sabha spent 46% of its time on legislative business.  The corresponding figure for Rajya Sabha is 51%.

38 Bills were introduced in Parliament during the Budget Session (excluding the Finance and Appropriation Bills).  28 Bills out of these were passed during this session.  This is the highest for any session in the last 10 years.

265 first-term MPs (Members of Parliament) have been elected to the 17th Lok Sabha.  The number of women MPs in the 17th Lok Sabha is 78.

94% of the first-term MPs participated in a debate in the Budget Session.  This is significantly higher than the 16th Lok Sabha where 82% of the first-term members participated in a debate in the first session.

Top Performers – Two Women MPs Top the Entire Lok Sabha

The performance of Members is evaluated by their Initiated Debates, Private Members Bills and Questions.

Ms Supriya Sule (NCP, Maharashtra) participated in 34 Initiated Debates, introduced 4 Private Members Bills and raised 109 Questions, bringing the total tally to 147.  She is a third-time MP.  She had secured the No 1 position in the 16th Lok Sabha also.  She is a Sansad Ratna Awardee.

Dr Heena Vijayakumar Gavit (BJP, Maharashtra) participated in 12 Initiated Debates and raised 106 questions with a total tally of 118.  She is a second-time MP.  She was honoured with Sansad Ratna Awards consecutively for four years during the 15th Lok Sabha.

PreSense congratulates both of them for their excellent performance during the first session of the 17th Lok Sabha.

The 17th Lok Sabha has started with a big bang.  It is hoped that the Members will continue to maintain this high spirit and guide the nation towards prosperity.

By G Priya Dharshni, Deputy Editor, PreSense
(Data and graphics Source: PRS Legislative Research)

Published in August 2019 issue of eMagazine PreSense

Friday, March 1, 2019

eMagazine PreSense launches a new tool to evaluate the performance of Lok Sabha


Prime Point Foundation, eMagazine PreSense and Sansad Ratna Awards Committee have now worked out a tool to evaluate the performance of Lok Sabha.   The norms have been worked in consultation with experts and Parliamentarians based on the rules, practices, paast averages and the capacity.   This tool is named as 'PreSense Lok Sabha Index'.  The tool is released  on 1st March 2019 in the February issue of PreSense.  The performance index of 14th, 15th and 16th Lok Sabha is as follows:

The norms are explained in the following table for better understanding.


Saturday, September 1, 2018

Performance of Individuals, Political Parties and States in the 16th Lok Sabha upto Monsoon Session 2018




The 15th Session of the Parliament (Monsoon Session 2018) adjourned sine die on August 10, 2018. Lok Sabha voted on a no-confidence motion which was won by the government. It also discussed issues related to the recent floods and drought in the country. Rajya Sabha discussed the final draft of the National Register of Citizens in Assam, non-implementation of the provisions of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganising Act, incidents of misuse of the social media and mob lynching.

Rajya Sabha also elected its Deputy Chairman. In addition, the supplementary demands for grants were discussed in Lok Sabha. 20 legislative Bills were introduced during the session and 18 were passed other than the two Appropriation Bills. Four Bills were withdrawn. Lok Sabha worked for 110% of the scheduled hours and Rajya Sabha for 68%.

Top Performers – Individuals

The top 5 performers of the 16th Lok Sabha from the first session till the end of the 15th Session (Monsoon Session 2018) are given below.  The table indicates the cumulative performance of the Members of Parliament (MPs) from the beginning of 16th Lok Sabha.

MP
Political party
Initiated Debates (ID)
Private Members Bills (PMB)
Questions (Qns)
Total of ID+PMB+ Qns
Attendance
Supriya Sule
Nationalist Congress Party
95
19
1049
1163
96%
Shrirang Appa Barne
Shiv Sena
111
20
998
1129
94%
Rajeev Shankarrao Satav
Indian National Congress
114
19
989
1122
81%
Dhananjay Bhimrao Mahadik
Nationalist Congress Party
49
3
1042
1094
73%
Shivaji Adhalrao Patil
Shiv Sena
25
13
985
1023
68%
Source: PRS India
All the MPs are from Maharashtra

Incidentally, all the top 5 performers are from the state of Maharashtra.  They are also Sansad Ratna Awardees in the previous years.

Performance of States

The average score of the 16th Lok Sabha till the end of the Monsoon Session per MP is 281.  Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Jharkhand have shown performance score of more than 400.  West Bengal and Jammu & Kashmir have shown poor performance.

States
MPs
Initiated debates (ID)
Sum of Private Member Bills (PMB)
Questions (Qns)
ID + PMB + Qns
Total
Average
Total
Average
Total
Average
Maharashtra
50
1910
39.8
187
24192
504.0
26289
547.7
Tamil Nadu
39
1482
39.0
0
15032
395.6
16514
434.6
Kerala
21
1711
81.5
80
7762
369.6
9553
454.9
Jharkhand
14
730
56.2
71
4793
368.7
5594
430.3
Karnataka
28
838
32.2
8
8462
325.5
9308
358.0
Rajasthan
27
1340
49.6
78
7719
285.9
9137
338.4
Delhi
7
303
50.5
67
1705
284.2
2075
345.8
Telangana
18
575
31.9
33
4533
251.8
5141
285.6
Haryana
10
418
52.3
24
1967
245.9
2409
301.1
Madhya Pradesh
31
867
31.0
20
6635
237.0
7522
268.6
Andhra Pradesh
25
852
35.5
15
5665
236.0
6532
272.2
Gujarat
26
645
24.8
55
6107
234.9
6807
261.8
Chhattisgarh
11
211
21.1
1
2070
207.0
2282
228.2
Odisha
22
908
43.2
63
4027
191.8
4998
238.0
Bihar
41
1669
43.9
101
6221
163.7
7991
210.3
Uttar Pradesh
83
2565
33.3
101
12073
156.8
14739
191.4
Assam
15
501
33.4
8
1937
129.1
2446
163.1
Uttarakhand
5
177
35.4
28
573
114.6
778
155.6
Punjab
15
472
33.7
11
1343
95.9
1826
130.4
West Bengal
46
1142
24.8
13
3462
75.3
4617
100.4
Jammu and Kashmir
7
120
20.0
1
346
57.7
467
77.8
National
20129
37.3
999
130598
241.8
151726
281.0
Source: PRS India
States with more than 5 MPs only are taken up for analysis

Performance of Political Parties

The following table indicates the cumulative performance of the political parties in the 16th Lok Sabha from the first Session till the 15th Session.   Shiv Sena and Nationalist Congress Party have shown very good performance.  They have done very well under ‘Questions’ category.  CPI (M) has done very well under ‘Debates’ category.  All India Trinamool Congress showed the poorest performance (average score for this party is 87.6 while the National average is 281). 

Out of 999 Private Members Bills, Members of Bharatiya Janata Party, Indian National Congress and Shiv Sena alone have introduced 760 bills.  Although All India Anna DMK with 37 MPs, has shown good performance with an average score of 444.7, their Members have not introduced even a single Private Members Bill. 

Row Labels
MPs
Initiated debates (ID)
Total Private Member Bills (PMB)
Questions
ID + PMB + Qns
Total
Average
Total
Average
Total
Average
Shiv Sena
18
842
49.5
74
10488
616.9
11404
670.8
Nationalist Congress Party
7
224
32.0
22
3597
513.9
3843
549.0
Communist Party of India (Marxist)
9
854
94.9
23
3137
348.6
4014
446.0
All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam
37
1471
39.8
0
14982
404.9
16453
444.7
Indian National Congress
49
1984
40.5
119
12624
257.6
14727
300.6
Yuvajana Sramika Rythu Congress Party
9
379
42.1
2
2219
246.6
2600
288.9
Telugu Desam Party
16
511
34.1
14
3744
249.6
4269
284.6
Bharatiya Janata Party
287
9133
34.6
567
59535
225.5
69235
262.3
Telangana Rashtra Samithi
12
445
37.1
30
2539
211.6
3014
251.2
Biju Janata Dal
21
908
43.2
63
4027
191.8
4998
238.0
Rashtriya Janata Dal
5
414
82.8
27
536
107.2
977
195.4
Samajwadi Party
7
116
16.6
1
1080
154.3
1197
171.0
Lok Jan Shakti Party
6
52
10.4
0
469
93.8
521
104.2
All India Trinamool Congress
38
817
21.5
8
2505
65.9
3330
87.6
National
20129
37.3
999
130598
241.8
151726
281.0
Source: PRS India
Only those political parties with more than 5 Members were considered for this analysis

PreSense congratulates all the top performers. 

We have already announced the Sansad Maha Ratna Guidelines for the 16th Lok Sabha.  Please click the link.


By K. Srinivasan, Publisher & Managing Editor 



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...